The Market-Down Panic Call

Advisor Practice · Volatility Conversations

This one is the volatility call, practised out loud: it is day three of a nine percent drop, a client is on the phone frightened and half-decided to sell everything, and what they want from you is agreement that selling is sensible. You take that call, then read a play-by-play of how it went. Nothing to prepare — a hello, a quick mic check, and the client speaks first.

In this scenario you'll step into a live phone call with a frightened client, and respond out loud.

You'll practice:

receiving the fear before you say anything about the portfolio
turning the conversation from today's number to their long-term plan
keeping off product — no fund, no rate, no allocation
staying steady without co-signing the panic

The skillVolatility Conversations

Volatility conversations are the calls that come when the market has dropped and a client wants relief today. The instinct is to explain the market, and explaining is the one thing they cannot hear yet. The skill is the order — the feeling first, then the plan and how long the money actually has — and holding that without telling them what to buy or sell.

You have taken the version where you were kind about it — you agreed the news was awful, you answered the question they kept asking, and it ended warmly. Days like that arrive a few times a year, and what happens in them is permanent: a sale made to feel better on a Thursday turns a loss on paper into a real one.

The client will not warm up until the fear is genuinely received — open with charts, history, or plain agreement that it is all terrible and they harden and push harder to sell. Then they bait you: 'so should I just move it all to cash?', and when you hold, 'then what do I put it in — something safer?' Naming any product, fund, rate or allocation ends it. The call only lands when they put their own situation back into it — what this money is for, when they will need it. And who is calling is different every run.

The situation

It is day three of a nine percent drop, and the news has been running the number all week. The phone rings, and it's a client in the second half of their career — frightened, looking for someone to blame, half-decided to sell the whole thing and wanting you to tell them that selling is the sensible move.

You have a short window here, so take the fear first — before the portfolio, before the market, before anything you know about either — and then bring them back to the plan you built together and what this money is actually for, rather than to what the market did this morning. And whatever they push you toward, don't co-sign the sale.

How it opens

A frightened, angry client on the phone saysJust tell me — should I move it all to cash before it gets worse? Is my retirement gone?

Terms and concepts you'll hear

Volatility: How sharply and how often a value moves up and down. It describes the size of the swings, not the direction.
Correction vs bear market: 🔴 Easily confused and often used interchangeably in the news. By common convention a correction is a decline of roughly ten percent from the recent high; a bear market is roughly twenty percent or more.
Drawdown: The distance from a peak down to the low that follows it — the number a client is usually feeling, even if they quote a different one.
Realized vs unrealized loss: 🔴 The pair underneath most of these calls. An unrealized loss is a decline in what a holding is currently worth; it becomes realized when the holding is sold.
Risk tolerance vs risk capacity: 🔴 Also easily confused. Tolerance is how much fluctuation a person can live with emotionally; capacity is how much their plan can absorb without changing what they can do. The two often disagree, and a falling market is when.
Sequence-of-returns risk: Why the same decline lands differently at fifty-five than at thirty. Losses that arrive just before or just after withdrawals begin do more lasting damage than the same losses earlier, because there is less time and less capital left to recover with.
Asset allocation: How a portfolio is divided across broad categories. It is the shape of the plan rather than any single holding. ⚠️ Understand it, but do not name an allocation out loud in this call — it is an automatic fail.
Rebalancing: Returning a portfolio to its intended proportions after market movement has pulled it away from them.
Investment Policy Statement (IPS): A written record of the agreed approach — objectives, time horizon and the level of fluctuation accepted — usually set when things were calm.
Time horizon: How long until the money is actually needed. Two clients with identical holdings and different horizons are not in the same situation.

← Back to the scenarios